The Commission has them recruited, inducted, trained and assigned Al Qaeda’s most ambitious attack plan within a two month time span, November to December 1999. Now looking at the witness testimony from the Philippines, there are multiple sightings of Mohammed Atta and Marwan al-Shehhi at the Woodland Park Resort near the former US air force Clark air base between 1997 and December 1999. Most importantly Atta was regularly seen there with a veteran US Air Force Master Sergeant, Melvin Troth. Retired Troth managed a flying club at Clark air base and was regularly seen collecting Mohammed Atta from Woodland Park Resort, as per the following witness statements.
Working closely with American Intelligence agencies, Filipino military investigators interviewed these witnesses immediately after 9/11. They confirmed Atta and Shehhi had visited the Philippines and stayed at Woodland Park multiple times between 1997 and 1999. But, after Melvin Troth and Samir said they didn't remember meeting the future 9/11 attackers, American investigators put this down to misidentification by the hotel staff, dismissed their statements and DID NOT PURSUE THIS LINE OF INQUIRY ANY FURTHER. One of the Filipino investigators will very likely have been Colonel Rodolfo Mendoza, a veteran terrorism investigator. After interogating the captured Bojinka Plot cell members who were arrested in January 1995, Colonel Mendoza wrote a memo warning of a 9/11 style kamikarze hijackiing and passed it to American security services:
The Hamburg Cell did meet with Osama bin Laden in 1999 Afghanistan but I don't think that was to get instruction or approval for the 9/11 plot. My research shows Saudi back, Afghan Wahhabi professor Abdul Rasul Sayyaf was the True 9/11 Mastermind - he was KSM's boss after all. I think that meeting was setup by Sayyaf to frame OBL and the Taliban (Sayyaf's enemies) for the 9/11 attacks. That'd be a favour to Sayyaf’s Saudi financiers as OBL represented a grave threat to the Saudi monarchy. I believe those assertions are evidenced by OBL's first statement about 9/11:
"I have already said that I am not involved in the September 11 attacks in the United States. As a Muslim, I try my best to avoid telling a lie. I had no knowledge of these attacks, nor do I consider the killing of innocent women, children and other humans as an appreciable act."
OBL would not have condemned the attacks if he knew he'd met its perpetrator Mohammed Atta. He did subsequently admit that his speeches and public statements might have inspired the attacks but, as far as I know, OBL never took or claimed credit for planning or ordering the attacks. I think Sayyaf's aim was to create and lead a Wahhabi state in Afghanistan, something he came very close to achieving with US and NATO backing. The world owes the Taliban a debt of thanks for preventing that.
The Hamburg Cell members did meet Slahi (aka The Mauritanian) in Duisburg, where Jarrah had lived before moving to Hamburg. Slahi was a senior Al Qaeda operator, receiving calls from his uncle in Afghanistan who was using Osama bin Laden's satillite phone. He instructed them on security, travel and arranged contacts in Pakistan who would take them to Afghanistan and Osama bin Laden. It must have been very good advice because by December 1999 they were in Afghanistan sat next to OBL. Confirmation of a September 1997 start date for the Hamburg Cell's 9/11 plot would cast Slahi's 1999 meeting with them in a very different light.