The Hamburg Cell
by Anthony C Heaford - @mancunianquiet on twitter - work-in-progress...
The four core members of the Hamburg Cell were three 9/11 pilots and Yemeni national Ramzi bin al-Shibh, now a forever prisoner in Guantanamo. Shibh survived because he couldn't get a US visa to take part in the attacks. He is the original 20th hijacker, likely the intended fourth pilot who was replaced by Hani Hanjour. In custody since 11 September 2002 (captured in Pakistan) Shihb has been tortured to a point where the court ruled he no longer has the mental capacity to stand trial. I think that was done intentionally and that I've unwittingly aggravated his mental torture due to my revealing (in 2015) my connection to Shibh from a 1997 business trip to Yemen. On Thursday 25 September 1997 I had dinner with Shibh's double at my hotel in Taiz city, the same month cell member Ziad Jarrah abruptly switched studies from dentistry in north Germany to aircraft engineering in Hamburg. Based on that abrupt course change and my meetings and conversations in Yemen, I think September 1997 marked the start of 9/11 planning by the Hamburg Cell. That would give them a more realistic four years to prepare for their mission (and certain death). The 9/11 Commission claims the cell's preparation was done in 21-months, beginning December 1999 during their visit to Afghanistan. How certain am I of my claim that the plot began in 1997? Three facial recognition programs match Shibh and my dinner companion Yousef’s faces, and a police identification specialist confirmed they were very likely blood relatives - brothers or cousins. My certainty that they are related is 100% - there’s simply too much corroborating evidence for this to be coincidental.
Ramzi bin al-Shibh called these flight manuals his Hamburg souvenirs
(Source: Yosri Fouda's 2002 interview with Shibh & KSM)
Yousef - Ramzi bin al-Shibh
Brothers or cousins?
Yousef & me at my hotel in Taiz
The Hamburg Cell, the Philippines & a US Air Force Veteran
Some of the best open source Intel supporting my claim that 9/11 planning began in 1997 comes from comparing the 9/11 Commission Report's narrative to witness statements. Those statements place Hamburg Cell members Mohammed Atta and Marwan al-Shehhi in the Philippines multiple times between 1997 and December 1999, and Atta regularly being collected by the manager of a local flying club. That manager was veteran US Air Force Master Sergeant, Melvin Troth who worked at the US Air Force's Clark air base in the Philippines before retiring there in 1986. Looking at the Commission's timeline and claims first:
"In September 1997, Jarrah abruptly switched his intended course of study from dentistry to aircraft engineering—at the Technical University of Hamburg-Harburg." - (page 163)
Despite knowing the cell began gathering in Hamburg in September 1997 - when Ziad Jarrah moved there - the Commission claims they weren't recruited to Al Qaeda until 1999, and then it was randomly by a stranger on a train:
"The available evidence indicates that in 1999, Atta, al-Shibh, Shehhi, and Jarrah decided to fight in Chechnya against the Russians. According to al-Shibh, a chance meeting on a train in Germany caused the group to travel to Afghanistan instead." - (page 165)
"Atta and Jarrah left Hamburg during the last week of November 1999… Shehhi left for Afghanistan around the same time; Al-Shibh about 2-weeks later." - "The new recruits from Germany possessed an ideal combination of technical skill and knowledge… Bin Laden and Atef wasted no time in assigning the Hamburg group to the most ambitious operation yet planned by Al Qaeda." - (page 166)
The Commission has them recruited, inducted, trained and assigned Al Qaeda’s most ambitious attack plan within a two month time span, November to December 1999. Now looking at the witness testimony from the Philippines, there are multiple sightings of Mohammed Atta and Marwan al-Shehhi at the Woodland Park Resort near the former US air force Clark air base between 1997 and December 1999. Most importantly Atta was regularly seen there with a veteran US Air Force Master Sergeant, Melvin Troth. Retired Troth managed a flying club at Clark air base and was regularly seen collecting Mohammed Atta from Woodland Park Resort, as per the following witness statements.
Clark Air Force Base, Mohammed Atta and the Woodland Park Resort
Woodland Park employee Victoria Brocoy told 9/11 investigators that between 1997 and 1999 they had many Arab guests, including Mohammed Atta and Marwan al-Shehhi. Brocoy said they were always accompanied by Samir, a Tagalog (Filipino) speaking Jordanian Arab with a travel agency in Manila. She said Atta was very private but often had a Filipina stay in his hotel room overnight - a different woman each time. Woodland security guard Antonio Sersoza said:
“I am sure Shehhi had been a Woodland guest several times in 1997. I remember him well because I flagged his speeding car at least three times at the gate of Woodland.”
Victoria Brocoy specifically recalled Atta and Shehhi staying at Woodland for a week in April 1999. She said Atta was taking flying lessons at the nearby Angeles City Flying Club (she did not recall Shehhi going with him). Woodland security guard Ferdinand Abad spoke with Atta that April when Atta asked about transport to the Flying Club. Abad then saw Atta, who had registered at the resort under his own name, collected regularly by US Air Force veteran Melvin Troth. When Atta stayed at Woodland Park in December 1999 Abad again saw him (but not Shehhi) being picked-up by Melvin Troth, at least five times he said. Woodland waitress Gina Marcelo remembered a party thrown by Shehhi that December:
“There were about seven people. They rented the open area by the swimming pool… They drank Johnnie Walker Black Label whiskey and mineral water. They barbecued shrimp and onions. They came in big vehicles, and they had a lot of money. They all had girlfriends.”
Working closely with American Intelligence agencies, Filipino military investigators interviewed these witnesses immediately after 9/11. They confirmed Atta and Shehhi had visited the Philippines and stayed at Woodland Park multiple times between 1997 and 1999. But, after Melvin Troth and Samir said they didn't remember meeting the future 9/11 attackers, American investigators put this down to misidentification by the hotel staff, dismissed their statements and DID NOT PURSUE THIS LINE OF INQUIRY ANY FURTHER. One of the Filipino investigators will very likely have been Colonel Rodolfo Mendoza, a veteran terrorism investigator. After interogating the captured Bojinka Plot cell members who were arrested in January 1995, Colonel Mendoza wrote a memo warning of a 9/11 style kamikarze hijackiing and passed it to American security services:
“With regards to their plan to dive-crash a commercial aircraft at the CIA headquarters, subject alleged that the idea of doing same came out during his casual conversation with [Ramzi Yousef] and there is no specific plan yet for its execution. What the subject [has] in his mind is that he will board any American commercial aircraft pretending to be an ordinary passenger. Then he will hijack said aircraft, control its cockpit, and dive it at the CIA headquarters. He will use no bomb or explosives. It is simply a suicidal mission that he is very much willing to execute.”
That is the clearest and earliest of warnings about the aspirations of Khalid Sheikh Mohammed's terrorist network. America was told the exact 9/11 attack method in 1995 but today their combined Intelligence agencies continue to claim 9/11 could not have been predicted. KSM's success was due to "a failure of imagination" by US Intel agencies the 9/11 Commission concluded. But I think this is still a massive and open line of inquiry, one that validates my claim of a 1997 start date for the Hamburg Cell planning 9/11. To my mind December 1999 marked the end of the planning stage that had occured in Hamburg. The visit the Afghanistan had one purpose - to implicate Osama bin Laden in a plot that was Masterminded by KSM and his boss Abdul Rasul Sayyaf. I guess their last visit to and the party at Woodland Park that December was a celebratory side trip for Atta and Shehhi before embarking on their suicidal mission. Six months later, in June 2000, they began arriving in America.
My Philippines Link to the Hamburg Cell via a US Veteran
My old workmate Dave Dean lived next door to Clark air base in the early 1970s, running a go-go bar / brothel for US service personnel. Dean was a 101st Airborne veteran of the 1969 Battle for Hamburger Hill in Vietnam and told me he was medically discharged soon after the battle due to a training accident. He said he'd spent the rest of the war in the Philippines running the bar. I was in the Philippines in 1994 where, after being caught smoking a joint in Manila, I'd spent a night in jail. The last time I saw Dean, in 1997 Chicago (his home town), he told me he could have sorted my legal trouble out in Manila with one phone call, showing his top level connections in the Philippines for more than 20+ years. Is it possible Dean knew Melvin Troth? Dean died by drowning in Lake Hartwell on 8 January 2020, two days after I'd accused him of providing material support to Khalid Sheikh Mohammed's terror cell in 1997 Yemen. I was last in the Philippines in February 1998, sent to install a printing machine in Manila. In retrospect it was an unusual business trip (detailed in My 9/11 Timeline) that I now think was related to my visit to Yemen 5-months earlier. The machine sale to Yemen was setup by Dean, operating from the shadows (clandestinely) in April 1997 Chicago.
A now surreal memory of mine from 1994 Manila was seeing a group of south Asian / Arabic men in smart casual attire. They walked in front of us for a minute, standing out amongst the mainly Caucasian backpackers. They went into the Hobbit House restaurant, a venue the Bojinka cell visited and not far from this cafe front with a crashing plane installed in an upstairs window. With memories of the 1993 World Trade Center bombing still fresh in my mind, seeing that plane in 1994 Manila made me think of kamikarze piloted terrorist attacks. I think the group I saw was the Bojinka Plot cell and I'd bet the plane installation inspired Ramzi Yousef's musings too. There is a bin Laden link to the Philippines but not from Osama. It was his brother-in-law Mohammed Jamal Khalifa, supporting the Abu Sayyaf Group on behalf of
Abdul Rasul Sayyaf. Abu Sayyaf were named and trained by Sayyaf, as were KSM and his nephew Ramzi Yousef. Yousef was in the Philippines in 1992 too, teaching Abu Sayyaf bomb making. Clearly KSM's network felt at home in the Philippines, even after the Bojinka Plot cell was busted in 1995 Manila.
The Manila bar front that inspired both mine and Ramzi Yousef's 9/11 predictions in 1994. Who owned that bar? Melvin Troth or Samir maybe, or possibly even Dave Dean.
The Hamburg Cell's Actual Timeline
Prior to embarking on their insurgent careers Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and his nephew Ramzi Yousef both studied in Western countries, engineering in America and electronics in Britain respectively. I guess the Hamburg Cell members were doing the same – getting an education while looking for opportunities to advance their cause. That cause, their grievance, can be summed up in three words: American Foreign Policy. I think the Hamburg Cell were willing to fight, kill and die for that cause before 1997. That's why Ziad Jarrah was able to change course and move to Hamburg at the drop-of-a-hat in September 1997, prompted I believe by my conversations in Yemen on 22/23 September. In 1996 Egyptian Mohammad Atta, the son of a Cairo lawyer, was studying architecture in Germany and appeared to have a good life and promising future. But that didn’t stop him pledging to sacrifice all that for a greater cause, signing his martyrdom will at Al Quds mosque in Hamburg on 11 April 1996. The timing is critical given it was also the first day of Israel’s murderous Operation Grapes of Wrath in Lebanon. Being of a similar age (Atta was born 1968 and me in 1970) we both grew up watching America’s war in Vietnam, terrorism, wars, famines and genocides reported routinely on the news. And, given my conversation with Yousef in 1997 Yemen that gained me access to Al Qaidah town the next morning, Atta and I had a similar perspective on events. One comment Yousef made stuck me deeply; he lamented the 1995 assassination of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, calling it “a lost last chance for peace”. I guess Atta felt the same as Yousef and the Grapes of Wrath operation was a last straw for him, provoking him to sign his martyrdom will. The Al Quds mosque preached the Wahhabi / Salafi ideology (that I see as a Muslim parallel to Christianity’s Ku Klux Klan) and was undoubtedly a networking center of a much larger extremist organization. If Atta wasn’t already connected to those networks then signing his will at Al Quds on 11 April 1996 will have plugged him straight in. That’s how he will have known Jarrah who was living in Greifswald north Germany before moving to Hamburg. Another resident of Greifswald at that time was everyone’s favourite Al Qaeda member, Mohamedou Slahi.
Ziad Jarrah and Mohammed Atta in Afghanistan in January 2000
The former senior Al Qaeda operative Mohamedou Slahi in 2016, suing the Canadian government for $28-Million





Work-in-Progress...




1968 to 1995
Future Hamburg Cell members and I are radicalized just by watching the news.

1996
Following Israel’s Grapes of Wrath and Madeline Albright saying “ …we think the price is worth it" when asked about the deaths of 500,000 Iraqi children due to US / UN sanctions, the Hamburg Cell members decided reciprocal violence was the best / only possible response. This is when they networked with senior Al Qaeda operators in Germany, men like Mohamedou Salahi, looking for opportunities to strike back and exact their revenge.
24 September
1997
KSM activated the 9/11 plot after my conversations with two Pakistani members of his network on 22/23 September. He assigned planning to the networked sleepers in Germany. That was likely done through Ramzi bin al-Shibh who was travelling between Yemen and Germany in 1997. The future cell members were like coiled springs, as evidenced by Ziad Jarrah’s abrupt course change before the end of the month. Confirming the exact date that request was submit will, if it is after the 22 September, help validate my claims.
October 1997
to
March 1998
Atta and Shibh travel abroad, likely meeting KSM first, to discuss the plan's viability. That may have occured in Yemen or Dubai, the hijacker's main logistics hub. I will have been a major topic of conversation and they will have survey me during two very unusual business trips I made to Dubai's Jebel Ali Free Zone in December 1997 and March 1998 (as detailed in My 9/11 Timeline). I think they will have met the Saudi muscle hijackers at the Base by Al Qaidah town that I visited on the last day of my business trip to Yemen.
* Estalishing which cell members were seen at Woodland Park Resort in 1997 and when they were there would be a fascinating to see if it was before or after I think the cell was activated.
1998 to 1999








Work-in-Progress...





The Hamburg Cell did meet with Osama bin Laden in 1999 Afghanistan but I don't think that was to get instruction or approval for the 9/11 plot. My research shows Saudi back, Afghan Wahhabi professor Abdul Rasul Sayyaf was the True 9/11 Mastermind - he was KSM's boss after all. I think that meeting was setup by Sayyaf to frame OBL and the Taliban (Sayyaf's enemies) for the 9/11 attacks. That'd be a favour to Sayyaf’s Saudi financiers as OBL represented a grave threat to the Saudi monarchy. I believe those assertions are evidenced by OBL's first statement about 9/11:
"I have already said that I am not involved in the September 11 attacks in the United States. As a Muslim, I try my best to avoid telling a lie. I had no knowledge of these attacks, nor do I consider the killing of innocent women, children and other humans as an appreciable act."
OBL would not have condemned the attacks if he knew he'd met its perpetrator Mohammed Atta. He did subsequently admit that his speeches and public statements might have inspired the attacks but, as far as I know, OBL never took or claimed credit for planning or ordering the attacks. I think Sayyaf's aim was to create and lead a Wahhabi state in Afghanistan, something he came very close to achieving with US and NATO backing. The world owes the Taliban a debt of thanks for preventing that.
The Hamburg Cell members did meet Slahi (aka The Mauritanian) in Duisburg, where Jarrah had lived before moving to Hamburg. Slahi was a senior Al Qaeda operator, receiving calls from his uncle in Afghanistan who was using Osama bin Laden's satillite phone. He instructed them on security, travel and arranged contacts in Pakistan who would take them to Afghanistan and Osama bin Laden. It must have been very good advice because by December 1999 they were in Afghanistan sat next to OBL. Confirmation of a September 1997 start date for the Hamburg Cell's 9/11 plot would cast Slahi's 1999 meeting with them in a very different light.
The one surviving Hamburg Cell member Ramzi bin-al-Shibh was arrested in 2002 and was the primary source for the hijacker / pilots activities as reported by the 9/11 Commission. Despite him being one of 9/11's most valueble witnesses he has been physically and psychologically tortured for the last twenty-plus years, first in secret CIA run prisons and then at Guantanamo. The Military Commission now claims he's too damaged to even stand trial.
I suspect al-Shibh's prime witness status is why he has been treated so mercilessly - the CIA literally destroyed evidence with their utterly pointless torture regime. Al-Shibh would undoubtedly be able to identify Yousef from my photo. I believe al-Shibh could be persuaded to go state witness, if I was given the opportunity to tell him the circumstances of my visit to KSM's front company in Yemen.
Ramzi bin al-Shibh's proof of life photo from Guantanamo
There’s evidence (pictured right) that Mohamedou Slahi setup clandestine communications networks for Al Qaeda sleeper cells using guest-book messaging on innocuous websites he created. That’s possibly how KSM activated the Hamburg Cell and the 9/11 plot from Yemen, via a guest-book message. The 9/11 Commission reported:
"When they later called Masri [from the recruitment meeting on a train] and expressed an interest in going to Chechnya, he told them to contact Abu Musab in Duisburg, Germany. Abu Musab turned out to be Mohamedou Ould Slahi, a significant Al Qaeda operator who, even then, was well known to US and German Intelligence, though neither government apparently knew he was operating in Germany in late 1999. When telephoned by al-Shibh and Shehhi, Slahi reportedly invited these promising recruits to come see him in Duisburg."